Economic Democracy and Business Governance in Meade’s Works
Keywords:Finance, Governance, Labour-managed firms, Welfare.
AbstractThe supposedly inefficient use of resources in producer cooperatives has been the object of eager debate among theorists for decades. This debate originated from the fact that Ward and Vanek, whose model had long been rated as a blueprint for the working of cooperatives, had reached the conclusion that their short-run behaviour was not Pareto-optimal. Their finding is highlighted by a downward sloping supply curve. The first solution suggested by Meade was differentiating the pay rates of workers assigned to the same jobs, in terms of fixing the incomes of new entrants at levels not exceeding the value generated by their work inputs. The Inegalitarian Cooperative does solve short-term problems, but fails to remove the odds faced by cooperatives when it comes to financing their investments and working capital. In later years, Meade proposes a new business form in order to deal with the last mentioned drawbacks. The business form concerned is the Discriminating Labour-Capital Partnership, whose microeconomic characteristics will be analysed in this paper. The issue discussed by Meade has great importance with regard to the current debate on social welfare because it provides a comprehensive reform of the fiscal and social policy by introducing, inter alia, a generalized and unconditional social dividend. The critical analysis of his works shows some weaknesses.
Amendola, A., 1988. Occupazione, investimenti e salario: gli effetti microeconomici della ‘profit sharing’. In Jossa B (ed.), Autogestione, cooperazione e partecipazione agli utili, (pp. 39-75). Bologna, Italy: Il Mulino.
Blanchflower D.G., Oswald A.J., 1987. Profit Sharing. Can it Work?. Oxford Economic Papers, 39: 1-19.
Bowles S., Gintis H., 1994. Credit Market Imperfections and the Incidence of Worker-Owned Firms. Metroeconomica, 45: 209-223.
Cugno F., Ferrero M., 1991. Il problema degli incentivi al lavoro nella produzione cooperativa. In Zamagni S, (ed.), Imprese e mercati. Torino, Italy: Utet.
Ellerman D.P., 1982. Economics, Accounting, and Property Theory. Lexington, MA: D. H. Heat.
Ellerman D.P., 1986. Horizon Problems and Property Rights in Labour Managed Firms. Journal of Comparative Economics, 10: 62-78.
Ellerman D.P., 1992. Property and Contract in Economics. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell
Fehr E., 1993a. The Labour-Capital Partnership: Reconciling Insider Power with Full Employment. In Atkinson A. B. (ed.), Alternatives to Capitalism: the Economics of Partnership. London, UK: Macmillan.
Fehr E., 1993b. The simple analytics of a membership market in a labor-managed economy. In Bowles, S., Gintis, H., Gustafsson B. (eds.), Markets and democracy: participation, accountability and efficiency. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Furubotn E.G., 1971. Toward a Dynamic Model of the Yugoslav Firm. The Cana¬dian Journal of Economics, 4, 182-197.
Furubotn E.G., 1974. Bank Credit and Labor-managed Firms - the Yugoslav Case, in Furubotn, E.G. & Pejovich, S. (eds.), The economics of property ri¬ghts, Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
Furubotn E.G., 1976. The Long-run Analysis of the Labor-managed Firm: An Al¬ternative Interpretation. The American Economic Review, 66, 104-123.
Furubotn E.G., 1978. The Long-run Analysis of the Labor-managed Firm: Reply. The American Economic Review, 68, 706-709.
Furubotn E.G., 1980a. The Socialist Labor-managed Firm and Bank-financed Invest¬ment: Some Theoretical Issues. Journal of Comparative Economics, 4, 184-191.
Furubotn E.G., 1980b. Bank Credit and The Labor-managed Firm: Reply. The American Econo¬mic Review, 70, 800-804.
Furubotn E.G., Pejovich S., 1970a. Tax Policy and Investment Decisions of the Yugoslav Firm. Na¬tional Tax Journal, 23, 335-348.
Furubotn E.G., Pejovich S. (1970b). Property Rights and the Behaviour of the Firm in a Socia¬list State. The Example of Yugoslavia. Zeitschrift fur Nationaloko¬nomie, 30, 431-454.
Furubotn E.G., Pejovich S., 1972. Property Rights and Economic Theory: a Survey of Recent Literature. Journal of Economic Literature, 10, 1137-1162.
Furubotn E.G., Pejovich S., 1973. Property Rights, Economic Decentralization and the Evolution of the Yugoslav Firm, 1965-72. Journal of Law and Economics, 16, 275-302.
Hahn F.H., Solow R., 1995. A Critical Essay on Modern Macroeconomic Theory. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
Lindbeck A., Snower D.J., 1986. Wage Setting, Unemployment and Insider-Outsider Relations. The American Economic Review, 76: 235-239.
Meade J.E., 1935. Outline of an Economic Policy for a Labour Government. In Howson S. (ed.), The Collected Papers of James Meade. Volume I: Employment and Inflation, London, UK: Unwin Hyman Ltd, 1988.
Meade J.E., 1938. An Introduction to Economic Analysis and Policy. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Meade J.E., 1945. Mr. Lerner on ‘The Economics of Control’. The Economic Journal, 55: 47-69.
Meade J.E., 1948. Planning and the Price Mechanism. The Liberal-Socialist Solution. London, UK: George Allen & Unwin.
Meade J.E., 1971. The Controlled Economy. London, UK: George Allen & Unwin.
Meade J.E., 1972a. The Theory of Labour-managed Firms and Profit Sharing. The Econo¬mic Journal, 82, 402-428.
Meade J.E., 1972b. Poverty in the Welfare State. Oxford Economic Papers, 24: 289-326.
Meade J.E., 1975. The Intelligent Radical’s Guide to Economic Policy: The Mixed Economy. London, UK: George Allen & Unwin.
Meade J.E., 1976. The Just Economy. London, UK: George Allen & Unwin.
Meade J.E., 1984. Full Employment, New Technologies and the Distribution of Income. Journal of Social Policy, 13: 129-146.
Meade J.E., 1989. Agathotopia. The Economics of Partnership, Aberdeen, UK: Aberdeen University Press (Italian edition: Agathotopia. L’economia della Partnership. Milano, Italy: Feltrinelli, 1989).
Meade J.E., 1990. Can we learn a ‘Third Way’ from the Agathotopians?. The Royal Bank of Scotland Review, n. 167: 15-28.
Meade J.E., 1991. The Building of the New Europe: National Diversity versus Continental Uniformity. Edingburgh, UK: The David Hume Institute.
Meade J.E., 1993. Liberty, Equality and Efficiency. Apologia pro Agathotopia Mea, Houndmills, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Meade J.E., 1995. Full Employment Regained? An Agathotopian dream. Cambridge, UK: Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge.
Nuti D.M., 1986a. L’economia della compartecipazione: critiche al modello di Weitzman. Politica ed Economia, n. 1: 53-64.
Nuti D.M., 1986b. Partecipazione e pieno impiego. Controreplica. Politica ed Economia, n. 4: 7-8.
Nuti D.M., 1988. Codeterminazione, partecipazione agli utili e cooperazione. In Jossa B. (ed.), Autogestione, cooperazione e partecipazione agli utili, (pp. 159-173). Bologna, Italy: Il Mulino.
Pejovich S., 1969. The Firm, Monetary Policy and Property Rights in a Planned Economy. Western Economic Journal, 7, 193-200.
Potestio P., 1988. Ambito di rilevanza e realismo della proposta di Weitzman di economia partecipativa. In Jossa B (ed.), Autogestione, cooperazione e partecipazione agli utili, (pp. 17-37). Bologna, Italy: Il Mulino.
Sertel M.R., 1982. Workers and Incentives, Amsterdam, Holland: North Holland.
Sertel M.R., 1987. Workers' Enterprises are not Perverse. European Economic Re¬view. 31: 1619-1625.
Tobin J., 1986. Inflation and Unemployment in the Share Economy. Journal of Comparative Economics, 10: 460-463.
Vanek J., 1970. The General theory of Labor-Managed Market Economies. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Wadhwani S., 1987. The macroeconomic Implications of Profit-Sharing. Some Empirical Evidence. Economic Journal, Supplement, 97: 171-183.
Ward B.N., 1958. The Firm in Illyria; Market Syndicalism. The American Economic Review, 48: 566-589.
Weitzman M.L., 1974. Prices vs. Quantities. Review of Economic Studies, 41: 477-491.
Weitzman M.L., 1982. Increasing Returns and the Foundations of Unemployment Theory. Economic Journal, 92: 787-804.
Weitzman M.L., 1983. Some Macroeconomic Implications of Alternative Compensation Systems. Economic Journal, 93: 763-783.
Weitzman M.L., 1984. The Share Economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Weitzman M.L., 1985a. Profit Sharing as Macroeconomic Policy. The American Economic Review, 75: 41-45.
Weitzman M.L., 1985b. The Simple Macroeconomics of Profit Sharing. The American Economic Review, 75: 937-953.
Weitzman M.L., 1987. Steady State Unemployment under Profit Sharing. The Economic Journal, 97: 96-105.
Zanella G., 2001. Partecipazione con avversione al rischio e coordination failures: riconsiderazione e tentativo di sintesi dei modelli di Weitzman e Meade. Rivista di Politica Economica, 91: 119-156.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) after official publication, as it can lead to productive exchanges as well as greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).